Personalized Stuffed Animals

  • $
    -
    $
Showing 133 products
Gray plush bunny sitting among flowers, with a tea set on a table in front.Plush toy rabbit with long ears on a white background
Personalize Me!

Big Nibble 20" Bunny - Gray

6 reviews
$72.95
Close up of cream plush bunny in a garden setting, sitting near a tea set.A 20-inch tall plush toy rabbit in a cream color with long ears, embroidered features, and a soft texture.
Personalize Me!

Big Nibble 20" Bunny - Cream

18 reviews
$72.95
Beige plush bunny sitting on a wooden bench outdoorsBeige plush bunny toy on a white background
Personalize Me!

Grand 41" Floppy Nibble Bunny - Almond Joy

$299.95
Bigger 26" Floppy Nibble Bunny - Almond Joy-Stuffed Animal-SKU: 824329 - Bunnies By The BayBigger 26" Floppy Nibble Bunny - Almond Joy-Stuffed Animal-SKU: 824329 - Bunnies By The Bay
Personalize Me!

Bigger 26" Floppy Nibble Bunny - Almond Joy

$144.95
Grand 41" Floppy Nibble Bunny - Gray-Stuffed Animal-SKU: 190355 - Bunnies By The BayGrand 41" Floppy Nibble Bunny - Gray-Stuffed Animal-SKU: 190355 - Bunnies By The Bay
Personalize Me!

Grand 41" Floppy Nibble Bunny - Gray

$299.95
Two young girls sitting on a couch with stuffed animals, smiling at each other.Brown and white plush dog toy on a white background
Personalize Me!

Sweet Floppy Mutt - Cocoa

$59.95
Child holding a plush toy on a soft surfaceBrown and white plush dog toy on a white background
Personalize Me!

Sweet Floppy Mutt - Toffee

$59.95
Gray plush dog toy on a textured surface with a blurred person in the backgroundGray plush dog toy with a white patch on a white background
Personalize Me!

Sweet Floppy Mutt - Steel

$59.95
Child holding a brown plush dog toy outdoorsBrown and white plush dog toy on a white background
Personalize Me!

Little Floppy Mutt - Cocoa

$34.95
Two plush dogs sitting on a metal tray with green foliage in the backgroundBrown and white plush dog toy on a white background
Personalize Me!

Little Floppy Mutt - Toffee

$34.95
Child holding a plush toy in front of a natural background with flowers and greeneryGray plush dog toy on a white background
Personalize Me!

Little Floppy Mutt - Steel

$34.95
Baby Bun Bun-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayBaby Bun Bun-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay
Personalize Me!

Baby Bun Bun

$32.95
Child smiling and holding a yellow plush cat outdoors.A plush stuffed animal resembling a yellow cat with a cream scarf, featuring embroidered details on its face.
Personalize Me!

Alley Cat

17 reviews
$34.95
Plush toy highland cow on a wooden surface with a blurred natural backgroundPlush toy Highland cow with a checkered scarf on a white background
Personalize Me!

Hamish the Highland Cow

$54.95
Stuffed cow toy on a wooden surface with a person wearing a denim jacket.A plush toy cow with cream and mocha brown shaggy fur, blue polka dot bandana around its neck, and a tuft of white hair on its head.
Personalize Me!

Moo Moo the Cow

12 reviews
$34.95
Child wearing a beige corduroy dress holding a plush pig toy with a dark backgroundPlush pig toy with a pink checkered scarf on a white background
Personalize Me!

Hammie the Pig

22 reviews
$34.95
Child smiling and hugging a plush horse and sheep, each with scraggly fur and soft accents.A plush toy horse with a brown fur body, cream muzzle, and cocoa brown fur mane and tail. It has bead eyes and is wearing a green and white bandana scarf.
Personalize Me!

Pony Boy Horse

4 reviews
$34.95
Child smiling and holding a plush lamb toy on a soft surface.Beige sheep stuffed animal, with embroidered face and rosy cheeks, that has a green and white checkered bandana and scraggly fur.
Personalize Me!

Shep the Sheep

7 reviews
$34.95
Pig stuffed animal in a wicker basket, in a sunny garden.A large plush toy pig with soft pink shaggy fur, embroidered details, and a red and white striped collar.
Personalize Me!

Big Hammie the Pig

$79.95
A plush cow and pig, sitting in a wicker basket in a garden. A large plush cow with cream and mocha brown shaggy textured fur, with embroidered details and a tuft of fur on its head.
Personalize Me!

Big Moo Moo the Cow

$79.95
Brown plush fox wearing a blue bandana with 'Camp Cricket' on it.Brown fox with a blue bandana on a white background
Personalize Me!

Foxy the Fox with Scarf

$44.95
Plush toy bunny with a blue scarf on a white backgroundFox and bunny stuffed animals, one brown and one white, sitting on a wooden ladder with 'Oliver' embroidered one one of their bandanas.
Personalize Me!

Harey the Bunny Rabbit with Scarf

$41.95
Little Naptime Nibble Blossom Bunny-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayLittle Naptime Nibble Blossom Bunny-Stuffed Animal-SKU: 190571 - Bunnies By The Bay
Personalize Me!

Little Naptime Nibble Blossom Bunny

$32.95
Plush bunny toy on a wooden surface with a book in the background.A soft gray plush bunny with white accents on the muzzle, tail, and ears, lying on its side.
Personalize Me!

Little Naptime Nibble Bloom Bunny

$32.95

Personalized Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys

Explore our collection of personalized plush toys, including personalized newborn stuffed animals! All of these sweet friends are super soft, hand-washable, and parent-approved. Whichever plush toy you choose is sure to become your wee one’s new favorite cuddle companion. We have the perfect stuffed pals for your baby girl or baby boy.

CUSTOM-EMBROIDERED STUFFED ANIMALS

Our custom stuffed animals are the perfect gift to celebrate your little one. They make great gifts for baby showers, birthdays, or any special milestone. For an extra personal touch, add a custom sweet message, birthday, or name in fine embroidery. We offer multiple font choices, thread colors, and even monograms!

Be sure to shop our full set of customized baby gifts. 


Recently viewed