Personalized Stuffed Animals

  • $
    -
    $
Showing 131 products
Black and white plush dog with a red bandana sitting outdoors next to a yellow plush cat.A plush toy resembling a black and white farm dog with floppy ears, wearing a red bandana with white dots.
Personalize Me!

Pepper the Farm Dog Plush

1 review
$39.95
Baby in a white onesie lying next to a plush bunny buddy blanket toy on a soft surfacefront view White bunny plush toy with a blue blanket on a white background
Personalize Me!

Bud Bunny Buddy Blanket

47 reviews
$34.95
Taupe and white bunny plush in a green outfit with a cream hat.Limited Edition - 40th Anniversary Bramble the Bunny-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay
Personalize Me!

Limited Edition - 40th Anniversary Bramble the Bunny

$74.95
Taupe and white bunny in purple dress with floral accents. Limited Edition - 40th Anniversary Thistle the Bunny-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay
Personalize Me!

Limited Edition - 40th Anniversary Thistle the Bunny

$74.95
Stuffed animal wearing a yellow polka dot hat with a blurred backgroundA plush seagull toy with a gray and cream pinstripe knit, orange feet and beak, and a yellow polka dot sou'wester.
Personalize Me!

Gulliver Seagull

7 reviews
$32.95
Lifestyle shot of Four bunny pacifier holders on a light grey backgroundfront view of a gray plush bunny toy in with a pacifier attached to it.
Personalize Me!

Bloom Bunny Silly Buddy

19 reviews
$22.95
Baby in white outfit using a grey pacifier with a tan puppy pacifier holderfront view of a plush pacifier holder toy in the shape of a puppy with a brown spot on its head.
Personalize Me!

Best Friend Skipit Puppy Silly Buddy

28 reviews
$22.95
Bun Bun Bunny Silly Buddy-Lovey - Silly Buddy-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayBun Bun Bunny Silly Buddy-Lovey - Silly Buddy-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay
Personalize Me!

Bun Bun Bunny Silly Buddy

18 reviews
$22.95
Blossom Bunny Silly Buddy-Lovey - Silly Buddy-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayBlossom Bunny Silly Buddy-Lovey - Silly Buddy-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay
Personalize Me!

Blossom Bunny Silly Buddy

13 reviews
$22.95
Baby sleeping, using white lamb pacifier holder, holding an orange pacifierfront view of a white plush lamb pacifier holder with embroidered details, safe for all ages.
Personalize Me!

Kiddo Silly Buddy

22 reviews
$22.95
lifestyle shor of four plush pacifier holder toys, including a dog, rabbit, lamb and bear, on a white backgroundfront view of brown teddy bear pacifier holder plush toy, designed for babies.
Personalize Me!

Cubby the Bear Silly Buddy

7 reviews
$22.95

Personalized Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys

Explore our collection of personalized plush toys, including personalized newborn stuffed animals! All of these sweet friends are super soft, hand-washable, and parent-approved. Whichever plush toy you choose is sure to become your wee one’s new favorite cuddle companion. We have the perfect stuffed pals for your baby girl or baby boy.

CUSTOM-EMBROIDERED STUFFED ANIMALS

Our custom stuffed animals are the perfect gift to celebrate your little one. They make great gifts for baby showers, birthdays, or any special milestone. For an extra personal touch, add a custom sweet message, birthday, or name in fine embroidery. We offer multiple font choices, thread colors, and even monograms!

Be sure to shop our full set of customized baby gifts. 


Recently viewed