Best Sellers

Child smiling and hugging a plush horse and sheep, each with scraggly fur and soft accents.

A plush toy horse with a brown fur body, cream muzzle, and cocoa brown fur mane and tail. It has bead eyes and is wearing a green and white bandana scarf.

Pony Boy Horse

$34.95

⭐Best Seller

Blossom Bunny Silly Buddy

$22.95

⭐Best Seller

Baby playing with a plush toy on a textured surface

A white plush lamb lovey with knotted arms and legs, designed for young children.

Sold out

Kiddo the Lamb Knotty Friend

$26.95

⭐Best Seller

Little Skipit 12" Pup

$34.95

⭐Best Seller

Plush owl toy on a tree branch with a natural background

A beige and brown plush owl toy with a scraggly fur body and knit stripe underwings, displayed against a white background.

Blink The Owl

$26.95

⭐Best Seller

Baby in white outfit using a grey pacifier with a tan puppy pacifier holder

front view of a plush pacifier holder toy in the shape of a puppy with a brown spot on its head.

Best Friend Skipit Puppy Silly Buddy

$22.95

⭐Best Seller

A beige plush bunny stuffed animal sitting on a weathered wooden surface outdoors, with tall green grass in the background. A second stuffed bunny is partially visible behind it. Both bunnies have patterned ears.

Big Apple NYC - FAO Schwarz Tiny 10" Floppy Nibble Bunny-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay

Big Apple NYC - FAO Schwarz Wee 10" Floppy Nibble Bunny

$29.95

⭐Best Seller

front view White plush lamb toy with a blanket on a white background

Kiddo the Lamb Buddy Blanket

$34.95

⭐Best Seller

Fluffy white rabbit plush toy with pink polka dot blanket on a soft surface

A pink and white plush bunny lovey with knotted arms and legs, featuring a sweet embroidered face and velour body.

Blossom Bunny Knotty Friend

$26.95

⭐Best Seller

Child hugging a fox plush toy in a woodland setting.

A plush toy representing a fox with a furry muzzle, fluffy tipped tail, embroidered features, and a velour nose, in shades of red, cream, and brown.

Foxy the Fox

$32.95

⭐Best Seller

Baby sitting on a textured surface holding a plush toy

A blue and white puppy lovey with knotted arms and legs, featuring a embroidered face and velour body.

Skipit Puppy Knotty Friend

$26.95

⭐Best Seller

Taupe and white bunny in purple dress with floral accents.

Limited Edition - 40th Anniversary Thistle the Bunny

$74.95

⭐Best Seller

Stuffed animal wearing a yellow polka dot hat with a blurred background

A plush seagull toy with a gray and cream pinstripe knit, orange feet and beak, and a yellow polka dot sou'wester.

Sold out

Gulliver Seagull

$32.95

⭐Best Seller

Blue stuffed octopus and orange crab stuffed animal sitting on a blue chair at a sandy beach

A blue plush octopus toy with a marina blue fur body, polka dots and stripes on the arms, and a jaunty sailor hat.

Ocho the Octopus

$42.95

⭐Best Seller

Fluffy white plush lamb with embroidered features and rosy cheeks, sitting on a gardening table.

A white plush lamb stuffed animal with embroidered features, including a face with brown eyes, a pink nose, and a smile.

Wee Kiddo the Lamb - White

$22.95

⭐Best Seller

Small child holding a white chicken stuffed animal, standing outside in a garden

A plush toy resembling a chicken with a shaggy cream fur body, striped red and cream legs, and bright orange feet and beak. It has hand-embroidered eyes and is sitting upright.

Clucky the Chicken

$34.95

⭐Best Seller

Baby Skipit

$32.95

⭐Best Seller

Baby in blue onesie holding blue and white bunny lovey

Front view of a plush blue and white bunny stuffed animal with a satin lined blanket

Bud Bunny Bye Bye Buddy

$26.95

⭐Best Seller

Two children sitting on a couch with plush toys, one holding a pink bunny.

Pink plush bunny toy on a white background

Sweet 16" Floppy Nibble Bunny – Pink

$49.95

⭐Best Seller

Plush toy rabbit with a tag on a white background

Tiny Nibble Bunny- Lilac Marble

$26.95

⭐Best Seller

Black and white plush dog with a red bandana sitting outdoors next to a yellow plush cat.

A plush toy resembling a black and white farm dog with floppy ears, wearing a red bandana with white dots.

Pepper the Farm Dog Plush

$39.95

⭐Best Seller

White bunny with a pink bow and tutu held by a person wearing a floral dress.

Cricket Island Blossom Bunny

$26.95

⭐Best Seller

Three teddy bears in a wicker basket on a light background

Brown teddy bear with a cream muzzle on a white background

Cubby the Bear

$32.95

⭐Best Seller

Stuffed cow toy on a wooden surface with a person wearing a denim jacket.

A plush toy cow with cream and mocha brown shaggy fur, blue polka dot bandana around its neck, and a tuft of white hair on its head.

Moo Moo the Cow

$34.95

⭐Best Seller

We love our customers and our customers love us, and especially these best-selling lovies, stuffed animals, books and other favorites!