Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys

Showing 308 products
A plush toy featuring a white sheep nestled inside a large orange pumpkin, with a smaller orange pumpkin on its head, sitting on a wooden surface against a dark background.A plush toy featuring a white sheep nestled inside a large orange pumpkin costume with a matching orange pumpkin hat, set against a plain white background.

Jack O’ Lantern Kiddo

$46.95
🌱New Arrival
Child holding a black cat plush toy against a dark backgroundBlack plush cat with striped arms and legs on a white background

Limited Edition - Boo Boo Kitty

4 reviews
$26.95
✨Glow in the Dark
Three colorful plush monsters on a wooden surface with a dark backgroundPurple plush bat toy with wings on a white background

Limited Edition - Eek The Bat

$26.95
✨Glow in the Dark
Child holding two plush toys, one purple and one green, against a dark background.Green plush monster toy with black and white striped accents on a white background

Limited Edition - Munch the Monster

$26.95
✨Glow in the Dark
Person holding a white plush lamb in an astronaut outfit with embroidered features and a plastic helmet.White plush lamb in an astronaut outfit with embroidered features and a plastic helmet.

Astronaut Kiddo The Lamb

$94.95
Graduation Kiddo-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayStuffed animal toy in graduation attire with a cap and gown on a white background
Sold out

Graduation Kiddo

$44.95
Limited Edition - Wow the Owl-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayLimited Edition - Wow the Owl-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay

Limited Edition - Wow the Owl

$16.95
✨Glow in the Dark
Haun-Ted the Ghost-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayHaun-Ted the Ghost-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay

Limited Edition - Haun-Ted the Ghost

$14.95
Trixie the Monster-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayTrixie the Monster-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay

Limited Edition - Trixie the Monster

$19.95
Trick-or-Treat Plush Set-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The BayThree colorful plush toys on a white background

Trick-or-Treat Plush Set

$79.95
✨Glow in the Dark
Girl holding a plush octopus toy on a beachA plush toy resembling a happy crab with a smiling face, big claws, and made in bright orange microfiber.

Happy Crab

7 reviews
$26.95
Blue stuffed octopus and orange crab stuffed animal sitting on a blue chair at a sandy beachA blue plush octopus toy with a marina blue fur body, polka dots and stripes on the arms, and a jaunty sailor hat.

Ocho the Octopus

18 reviews
$42.95
⭐Best Seller
Unicorn seahorse plush toy with colorful mane and horn on a beach backgroundPlush toy seahorse with unicorn horn and rainbow colors on a white background

Marco the Unicorn Seahorse

$19.95
Plush shark toy on a sandy surface with a blurred natural backgroundPlush shark toy on a white background

Axel the Shark

$44.95
Plush fish toy on a wooden surface with a blurred natural backgroundPlush toy fish with a smiley face on a white background

Gus the Guppie

$22.95
Colorful fish-shaped plush toy on a textured surface with a beach backgroundPlush toy fish with a smiley face on a white background

Gil the Guppie

$22.95

Find adorable stuffed animals by category:

From the very first weeks after their grand entrance, a little one’s stuffed animals are constant companions and a steady source of comfort throughout childhood. At Bunnies by the Bay, you’ll find premium collections of adorable stuffed animals and plush toys that your wee baby girl or boy will love and cherish for years to come, and even a special gift for those still Wee at heart, even adults love our stuffed animal friends. We offer small, medium, and large stuffed animals for babies; stuffed animal pacifier holders; animal baby blankets; and all kinds of other plush treasures from the animal kingdom.  Our stuffed animal collection ranges from Farm Friends, Sea Friends, and Woodland Pals to our famous Nibbles Bunnies with the softest long lop ears you will ever find.

If you’re on the lookout for security friends for your little one, check out our Silly Buddy pacifier holders. These cozy friends will ensure your baby’s pacifier is secure when you’re on the go. Shop our security items and you’ll also find our two-in-one Buddy Blankets and Bye Bye Buddies. Part blankie, part furry friend, and all lovable! 

When it comes to plush stuffed animals for babies, Bunnies by the Bay offers a collection you don’t want to miss. Whether you’re shopping for a friend’s upcoming baby shower or you’re looking to surprise your little bunny with a special gift, this is the perfect place to find something unique. And not just for babies, stuffed animals and plush toys are for everyone. Even grown-ups need soft friends to love, and luxury stuffed animals that easily create a perfect touch for home decor.


Recently viewed