Gender-Neutral Baby Toys

Two plush toys, a rabbit and a dog, sitting on a soft surface with a dark background.

Bud Bunny Cricket Island Friend

6

$26.95

Tiny Nibble 8" Bunny - Gray-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay

Personalize Me!

Tiny Nibble 8" Bunny - Gray

13

$26.95

Tiny Nibble 8" Bunny - Pink-Stuffed Animal-SKU: - Bunnies By The Bay

Pink plush bunny toy with a white tag on a white background

Personalize Me!

Tiny Nibble 8" Bunny - Pink

19

$26.95

Child wrapped in a gray and white quilt with a pink bow in her hair.

Baby quilt with gray and white checkered pattern and moon and star designs on a white background

Personalize Me!

Little Star Quilt

7

$169.95

White bunny chime rattle on a pastel header card

A soft white bunny rattle with embroidered features, including cheeks and ears, on a plain background.

Sold out

Friendly Chime White Bunny

5

$16.95

Blue baby rattle with a book titled 'Best Friends Indeed' on a white background

A soft blue velour puppy rattle with embroidered features, including puppy face and cheeks, with pinked cheery ears and soft dangling arms.

Friendly Chime Puppy - Blue

2

$16.95

A soft gray bunny rattle with embroidered features, including bunny ears and a face, with a tag attached showing a three-leaf clover.

Friendly Chime Gray Bunny

8

$16.95

Pink plush bunny and pink bunny rattle with carrot tag on a pink blanket next to a children's book

A soft pink velour baby rattle in the shape of a bunny with embroidered features and chime inside.

Friendly Chime Pink Bunny

5

$16.95

Three fluffy white sheep toys in a white basket on a wooden surface.

A soft white lamb rattle with embroidered features, including a face, ears, and arms. The toy has a friendly chime bell inside and is designed for infants.

Friendly Chime White Lamb

2

$16.95

Baby Soother - Pacifier & Teether In One-Pacifier-SKU: 730004 - Bunnies By The Bay

From Our FriendsSold out

Baby Soother - Pacifier & Teether In One

3

$9.95

Girl holding a plush octopus toy on a beach

Happy Crab

7

$26.95

Gift Card

From $25

White fluffy lamb plush toy on a shelf with books and other toys.

A plush stuffed lamb with a soft white coat, embroidered features, and pink cheeks.

Sold out

Kiddo the Lamb

14

$34.95

White lamb plush and 'Counting Peeps' book in a white wire basket.

Children's book titled 'Counting Peeps' with a sheep illustration on the cover.

Sold out

Counting Peeps Book

6

$17.95

Two white plush lamb toys and a book titled 'Counting Peeps' on a white background

Personalize Me!Sold out

Sweet Little Lamb Baby Gift Set

2

$82.95

Little Star Deluxe Baby Gift Set-Gift Set-SKU: 106044 - Bunnies By The Bay

Personalize Me!Sold out

Little Star Deluxe Baby Gift Set

3

$339.95

Bun Bun Lovey Baby Gift Set-Gift Set-SKU: 106053 - Bunnies By The Bay

Personalize Me!Sold out

Bun Bun Lovey Baby Gift Set

1

$109.95

Baby holding a buddy blanket plush bunny toy and pink blanket on a textured surface

front view of White bunny plush toy with attached pink blanket on a white background

Personalize Me!

Blossom Bunny Buddy Blanket

133

$34.95

Plush toy rabbit surrounded by plants with a blurred background

A small gray plush bunny with a velour face, dangly arms and legs, and an embroidered face with blushed cheeks.

On sale

Roly Poly Bloom - Gray Bunny

6

$16.99 $17.95

Gray plush bunny sitting among flowers, with a tea set on a table in front.

Plush toy rabbit with long ears on a white background

Personalize Me!

Big Nibble 20" Bunny - Gray

6

$72.95

Stuffed animal wearing a yellow polka dot hat with a blurred background

A plush seagull toy with a gray and cream pinstripe knit, orange feet and beak, and a yellow polka dot sou'wester.

Personalize Me!

Gulliver Seagull

7

$32.95

Child smiling and holding a yellow plush cat outdoors.

A plush stuffed animal resembling a yellow cat with a cream scarf, featuring embroidered details on its face.

Personalize Me!

Alley Cat

17

$34.95

What Will My Grandchild Call Me?

10

$22.95

Child smiling and hugging a plush horse and sheep, each with scraggly fur and soft accents.

A plush toy horse with a brown fur body, cream muzzle, and cocoa brown fur mane and tail. It has bead eyes and is wearing a green and white bandana scarf.

Personalize Me!

Pony Boy Horse

4

$34.95