Making a Baby Gift Basket When You Don’t Know the Gender

Gender-neutral baby showers are becoming more and more common. Some parents don’t want to celebrate traditional gender norms, others don’t even know their baby’s gender yet, and still others want it to be a surprise for loved ones. Whatever the case, you need to buy a gift for a baby and their parents, but you don’t know the gender. Therefore, you can’t go to the infant section of a store and put everything blue or pink in your cart.

So what do you do? Don’t worry, because Bunnies by the Bay is here with some advice. We’ll walk through everything you need to know about making a baby gift basket when you don’t know the gender. We’ll teach you how to select practical items every parent needs and still add a personal touch that is completely independent of boy or girl messaging.

Buy Baby Items Every Newborn and Parent Needs

Every baby requires certain fundamental items, and these are perfect foundations for your gift basket. Though all of these products come in gender-specific designs, plenty of neutral options exist as well. Let’s explore the key items you won’t want to exclude from your gift.

Diapers

Diapers top the list of universal necessities. Newborns use approximately 10–12 diapers daily during their first month, so the soon-to-be parents in your life are guaranteed to appreciate this practical item. Their wallets will certainly thank you!

Blankets

Who doesn’t love snuggling up in a blanket? Babies sure love it, and parents appreciate having plenty of cozy things around for their newborn to snuggle. Swaddle blankets are particularly helpful for putting fussy babies to sleep. Simply buy some blankets in soft, breathable fabrics with neutral designs.

Comfort Items

Blankets can be a comfort item, but this category extends to include anything a baby can use to soothe their anxiety, whether because of separation or another circumstance. These gifts help babies with their emotional regulation, which also helps parents feel better about their little ones. Some products to consider are pacifiers and soft toys (like stuffed animals).

Feeding Supplies

Feeding supplies make practical additions to your basket. Burp cloths, bibs, and bottles serve universal purposes. Even breastfeeding mothers often need bottles for pumped milk or supplemental feeding.

White-Noise Machine

This device emits soft, calming, constant noise that can help a baby relax and fall asleep. Parents are sure to appreciate this practical gift.

Bath-Time Goods

Bathing a newborn can feel tricky without the right supplies. That’s why some welcome additions in your gift basket will be gentle, fragrance-free baby soap, soft washcloths, and hooded towels. Parents appreciate having extras of these frequently used items.

Other Grooming Essentials

Diaper rash cream, baby lotion, and nail clippers are also great things to include to address common newborn needs. Choose products from reputable brands known for sensitive skin formulations. Hypoallergenic formulas are your best bet!

Remember To Stick to Neutral Colors

Newborn baby products are mostly blue or pink, so you might have to do some digging to find neutral colors. Despite this, choosing anything other than blue or pink is all you need to do. Yellow, green, orange, purple, gold, silver, white, cream, and more are still on the table!

We recommend adhering to a color theme, such as earthy tones or pastels. This will make all the products you buy look cohesive, both in the basket and in the nursery they’ll end up in.

Consider DIYing Some Gifts

Though you can’t make a white-noise machine on your own, you might be able to knit a cute cream-colored hat or a pair of mint-green socks for the newborn. This type of gift is extra meaningful because you invested your time. Moreover, handmade gifts give you the freedom to decorate outside of gender norms however you see fit.

Add Personal Touches Without Gender Assumptions

Personalization elevates gift baskets from purely practical to uniquely meaningful. At Bunnies by the Bay, that’s what we’re all about. Our unisex baby shower gifts are useful and customizable. From our Knotty Friends and Silly Buddies to stuffed animals and blankets, you can give each a personalized touch by embroidering a special message. Simply click the “Personalize Me” button on the product description, provide the text you want us to use, and then place your order.

We also suggest writing a thoughtful card to accompany your gift basket. Use the space to express your excitement for the parents-to-be and celebrate their bundle of joy. This is such a simple and easy touch that will mean so much to your friends.

Wrap the Gift Thoughtfully

The presentation of your gift basket contributes to its impact and memorability. For practical reasons, choose containers that parents can repurpose for nursery organization or storage. Wicker baskets, fabric bins, or wooden crates are great examples that serve dual purposes as gifts and future storage solutions.

Stick to natural materials such as burlap, kraft paper, or cotton fabrics to create sophisticated presentations. These materials are not only gender-neutral, but they also photograph well and align with contemporary nursery design trends favoring organic, sustainable elements.

Next, consider layering items to create visual interest and allow recipients to discover each component gradually. Place larger items (such as blankets or stuffed animals) as foundation layers, then add smaller items strategically throughout the basket.

Creating Lasting Memories With Your Special Gift Basket

If you were confused about making a baby gift basket when you don’t know the gender, we hope this advice has helped! Just remember that new parents value practical support above decorative items during those first few weeks. Items that solve problems, provide comfort, or save time are sure to be the most appreciated components of any gift basket. Then, you can make these functional gifts meaningful by personalizing them and including a card that speaks to the parents-to-be. Ultimately, by choosing items that celebrate the universal joy of new life rather than conforming to traditional gender expectations, you contribute to creating an inclusive, welcoming environment for the new arrival.

When you’re ready to start shopping, remember to browse the catalogue at Bunnies by the Bay. From loveys to storybooks, our products are perfect for baby shower gifts, including the gender-neutral ones!